Questions and Answers on Fluoride
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency today announced
that it has reevaluated the current
science on fluoride. EPA will rely on these new assessments
to review the existing maximum
level of fluoride allowed in drinking water and determine
whether its drinking water regulations
for fluoride should be revised. EPA will review the drinking
water standard to make sure that it
continues to protect against unwanted effects of excessive
exposure. EPA’s examination of the
fluoride drinking water public health goal and enforceable
standard will be based on this new
science, along with other information such as analytical methods
and treatment feasibility.
This fact sheet provides information on community water
fluoridation as well as current federal
activities to update guidance and regulations concerning
community water fluoridation. The
Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) oversees the
national water fluoridation
program. Existing
Drinking Water Standards for Fluoride
1)What is the current drinking water standard for fluoride?
2) What are the drinking water standards for fluoride? What
do you mean by an MCL, an
MCLG, and a secondary standard for fluoride? What is the
difference?
3) What are the public notification requirements if my
system exceeds the MCL or the
secondary standard for fluoride?
4) Why is EPA’s drinking water standard different than Department
of Health and Human
Service’s recommended optimal fluoridation level for
community drinking water systems?
Current EPA Actions
5) Why did the EPA decide to conduct new risk and exposure
assessments?
6) What were the findings of the new risk and exposure
assessments?
7) What has changed in your conclusions about risk from
fluoride?
Have we learned about new
health effects?
8) Does EPA plan to revise the fluoride drinking water
standard?
9) What is the next step for the EPA?
Fluoride Exposure
10) How does fluoride get into tap water?
11) Does my public water system add fluoride to the water?
12) Doesn’t fluoride occur naturally in water? What if my
water system has naturally-occurring fluoride above 4.0 mg/L?
13) Are there public water systems that exceed the drinking
water standard for fluoride? Why?
What do they do about it?
14) In addition to water, what are other specific sources of
fluoride?
15) Why has exposure to fluoride increased?
16) Does bottled water contain fluoride?
Potential Adverse Health Effects of Fluoride
17) What are the effects of excess levels of fluoride and
why are they different for children and
adults?
18) Are children or adults exposed to too much fluoride?
19) Who is at risk from excessive fluoride exposure?
What You Can Do
20) Is my child getting an appropriate amount of fluoride
from drinking water and tooth
brushing?
21) What can I do to limit my exposure to fluoride?
22) Are there methods I can use to remove fluoride from my
drinking water at home? For
example, boiling or use of commercially available water
filters and
units.
23) Should my children stop brushing their teeth with
fluoride toothpaste?
24) Should I reduce the number of times I brush my teeth
daily?
Existing Drinking Water Standards for Fluoride
1) What is the current drinking water standard for fluoride?
The current enforceable drinking water standard for fluoride
is 4.0 mg/L. This is the maximum
amount that is allowed in water from public water systems.
It is set to meet the current public
health goal for protection against increased risk of
crippling skeletal fluorosis, a condition
characterized by pain and tenderness of the major joints.
EPA also has a non-enforceable secondary standard for
fluoride of 2.0 mg/L, which is
recommended to protect children against the tooth
discoloration and/or pitting that can be caused
by excess fluoride exposures during the formative period
prior to eruption of the teeth. Although
water systems are not required to comply with secondary
standards, for fluoride, EPA does
require that systems notify customers if the average water
levels exceed the secondary standard.
2) What are the drinking water standards for fluoride? What
do you mean by
an MCL, an MCLG, and a secondary standard for fluoride? What
is the
difference?
The current enforceable drinking water standard for fluoride
is 4.0 mg/L. This is the maximum
amount that is allowed in water from public water systems,
also called the Maximum
Contaminant Level (MCL). The MCL is set to be as close to
the public health goal as EPA finds
may be achieved with the use of the best available
technology, taking cost into consideration.
The public health goal, called a Maximum Contaminant Level
Goal (MCLG), is not enforceable
and is based solely on possible health risks and exposure
over a lifetime. For fluoride, analyti
cal methods or treatment technology do not pose any
limitation so the MCL currently equals the
MCLG of 4.0. A secondary standard is a non-enforceable
guideline to regulate contaminants that may cause
cosmetic effects (such as skin or tooth discoloration) or
aesthetic effects (such as taste, odor, or
color of drinking water). EPA recommends secondary standards
to water systems but does not
require systems to comply. For fluoride, the secondary
standard is 2.0 mg/L.
3) What are the public notification requirements if my
system exceeds the
MCL or the secondary standard for fluoride?
Community water systems that exceed the fluoride MCL of 4
mg/L must notify persons served
by that system as soon as practical, but no later than 30
days after the system learns of the
violation. Community water systems that exceed the fluoride
secondary standard of 2 mg/L must notify
persons served by that system as soon as practical but no
later than 12 months from the day the
water system learns of the exceedance.
4) Why is EPA’s drinking water standard
different than Department of Health and Human Service’s
recommended optimal fluoridation level for community
drinking water systems?
EPA’s drinking water standard differs from the Department of
Health and Human Service’s
recommended optimal fluoridation level because the two
benchmarks have different purposes
and are set under different authorities. The EPA's
enforceable standard for the highest level of
fluoride that is allowed in public water supplies is 4.0
milligrams per liter, is set to protect
against risks from exposure to too much fluoride. The HHS
recommended optimal level of 0.7
milligrams per liter is set to promote public health
benefits of fluoride for preventing tooth decay
while minimizing the chance for dental fluorosis.
Current EPA Actions
5) Why did the EPA decide to conduct new risk and exposure
assessments?
In 2003, EPA reviewed the drinking water standard for
fluoride and found that new health and
exposure data were available on orally ingested fluoride.
EPA requested that the National
Research Council (NRC) of the National Academies of Science
(NAS) conduct a review of this
data and in 2006, the NRC published their evaluation in a
report entitled, Fluoride in Drinking
Water: A Scientific Review of EPA’s Standards. The NRC
recommended that EPA update its
fluoride risk assessment to include new data on health risks
and better estimates of total
exposure. The panel also recommended that EPA update its
public health goal to be protective
of pitting of tooth enamel, clinical stage II skeletal
fluorosis, and bone fractures, in addition to
the stage III skeletal fluorosis that is addressed by the current
public health goal.
6) What were the findings of the new risk and exposure
assessments?
These risk assessments consider new health effects data on
skeletal and dental fluorosis and also
update exposure estimates to reflect current conditions. Data
indicate that fluoride exposure
levels among the population have increased in the last 40 to
50 years resulting in an increase in
some effects on teeth. Based on the data presented in this
report, it is likely that some children
are exposed to too much fluoride at least occasionally. The
impact of the overexposure on the
risk for severe dental fluorosis in one or more teeth
depends on the frequency and duration of the
overexposures. EPA
has proposed a reference dose (RfD) of 0.08 mg/kg/day for protection against
pitting of the
tooth enamel (severe dental fluorosis) and concluded that
this value is also protective against
fractures and skeletal effects in adults. The reference dose
is the estimate of the daily exposure
that is likely to be without harmful effect during a
lifetime.
7) What has changed in your conclusions about risk from
fluoride? Have we
learned about new health effects?
The new assessments have clarified what we know about the
relationships between fluoride
exposure and dental fluorosis, bone fractures, and skeletal
fluorosis. The new assessments also
reflect updated exposure estimates that account for changes
in fluoridation practices and use of
consumer dental products since the original drinking water
standard was set.
8) Does EPA plan to revise the fluoride drinking water
standard?
At this time and with the finalization of the new risk
assessment, the Agency has not yet made a
decision about revising the drinking water standard for
fluoride. The Agency will review the
new risk assessment of fluoride along with other information
(e.g. analytical methods and
treatment feasibility, occurrence and exposure, etc) to
determine whether it is appropriate to
revise the drinking water standard.
9) What is the next step for the EPA?
The Agency will review the new risk assessment of fluoride
along with other information (e.g.
analytical methods and treatment feasibility, occurrence and
exposure, etc) to determine whether
it is appropriate to revise the drinking water standard.
Fluoride Exposure
10) How does fluoride get into tap water?
Fluoride can occur in drinking water naturally as a result
of the
geological composition of soils and bedrock. Some
areas of the country have high levels of naturally occurring
fluoride which
can dissolve easily into ground water as it moves through
gaps and pore spaces between rocks.
Fluoride can also be added to public drinking water supplies
as a public health measure for
reducing cavities among the treated population. Fluoridation
is not required by EPA, which is
prohibited by the Safe Drinking Water Act from requiring the
addition of
any substance to drinking water for preventive health care
purposes. The Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) provides recommendations about the optimal
levels of fluoride in drinking
water in order to prevent tooth decay. The decision whether
or not to add fluoride to drinking
water is made on a local basis. Consumers served by public
water systems who wish to learn
about fluoridation of their drinking water can visit the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)’s My
Water’s Fluoride (MWF) Web site at
http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/MWF/Index.asp.
11) Does my public water system add fluoride to the water?
If you have questions about whether your community has
fluoridated water, you can call y
our public water system. If you live in one of the 39 states
that participate in the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention’s “My Water's Fluoride” program, you
can go online and find
information on your water system’s fluoridation status. The
best way to find the fluoride level of
your local public water system is to contact your water
utility provider for more information.
Consumers can find the name and contact information of the
water utility on their water bill.
12) Doesn’t fluoride occur naturally in water? What if my
water system has
naturally-occurring fluoride above 4.0 mg/L?
Fluoride can occur in drinking water naturally as a result
of the geological composition of soils
and bedrock. Community water systems are required to ensure
that levels of fluoride in their
drinking water are less than 4.0 mg/L in order to be in compliance
with EPA drinking water
regulations. If your water system has naturally-occurring
fluoride above this level, t
he EPA requires systems to take action to reduce it. If you
want the most up-
to-date information about the current fluoride level in your
water, contact your local water supplier directly.
13) Are there public water systems that exceed the drinking
wate
r standard for fluoride? Why? What do they do about it?
A very small proportion of the public water systems
nationwide have exceeded the drinking
water standard for fluoride. In these cases, the high level
of fluoride is generally the result of
natural
background resulting from the geologic composition of local
soils and bedrock. When
routine monitoring indicates that fluoride levels are above
the MCL of 4 mg/L, the public water
system must take steps to reduce the amount of fluoride so
that it is below that level.
14) In addition to water, what are other specific sources of
fluoride?
Fluoridated toothpaste is another main source of fluoride
intake. Other fluoride-containing dental
products are applied or prescribed by a health care
professional such as gels, varnishes, pastes
and restorative materials. These products are used only
occasionally on the outside of the tooth
and do not contribute much to the total intake of fluoride.
Small amounts of fluoride can also
come from industrial emissions, phar
maceuticals and pesticides.
15) Why has exposure to fluoride increased?
Previously, the only source of exposure to fluoride was that
which occurred naturally in drinking
water or food as a result of the geological composition of
soils and bedrock. Currently, exposure
to fluoride comes from more sources including fluoridated
dental products such as toothpaste
and mouthwash, as well as the voluntary addition of fluoride
to drinking water, which some
systems do as a public health measure for reducing tooth
decay.
16) Does bottled water contain fluoride?
Bottled water products labeled as de-ionized, purified or
distilled have been treated in such a way
that they contain no or only trace amounts of fluoride,
unless they specifically list fluoride as an
added ingredient
. Other bottled water products (such as spring water) can
contain fluoride that is
added or naturally present in the original source of the
water. FDA sets limits for fluoride in
bottled water based on several factors, including the source
of the water. These limits range from
0.8 to 2.4 milligrams per liter. To learn more, check out
the CDC's Fact Sheet on Questions
about Bottled Water and Fluoride and FDA’s Website:
www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm203620.htm
Potential Adverse Health Effects of Fluoride
17) What are the effects of excess levels of fluoride and
why are they different
for children and adults?
Adults exposed to excessive consumption of fluoride over a
lifetime may have increased
likelihood of bone fractures, and may result in effects on
bone leading to pain and tenderness.
For effects to teeth, children are most likely to be
affected by excessive exposure to fluoride
because it impacts teeth while they are still in formative
phases. Children aged 8 years and
younger exposed to excessive amounts of fluoride have an
increased chance of developing pits in
the tooth enamel, along with a range of cosmetic effects to
teeth. For prevention of tooth decay,
the beneficial effects of fluoride extend throughout the
life span.
18) Are children or adults exposed to too much fluoride?
Based on the data evaluated in this risk assessment, EPA
concludes that it is likely that some
children 8 and younger are exposed to too much fluoride at
least occasionally while their
teeth are forming because of their high fluid intake
relative to their body weight and/or because of
high natural levels of fluoride in their local drinking
water. The impact of overexposure on the
risk for pitting of enamel in one or more teeth depends on
the frequency and duration of the overexposures.
http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm203620.htmhttp://www.cdc.gov/fluoridation/faqs/bottled_water.htmhttp://www.cdc.gov/fluoridation/faqs/bottled_water.htm
19) Who is at risk from excessive fluoride exposure?
Children are most likely to be affected by excessive
exposure to fluoride because it impacts teeth
while they are still in formative phases (birth through
formation of the wisdom teeth). EPA’s risk assessment compared age-specific
exposure estimates to the fluoride dose associated with pitted enamel and found
that children 8 and younger may be those most at risk. The maximum dose that is
protective for children will also protect adults from long-termeffects on bone.
What You Can Do
20) Is my child getting an appropriate amount of fluoride
from drinking water and tooth brushing?
Yes, if you and your child are among the 196 million
Americans who receive their water from an optimally fluoridated community water
system (0.7 to1.2 milligrams per liter) and you follow guidelines in your
child’s tooth brushing, then it is highly unlikely that your child is receiving
too much fluoride. Centers for Disease Control recommends that children under 6
who are using fluoride toothpaste should use a small, pea-sized amount on the
brush, spit out the excess paste, and rinse well after brushing. Begin using
toothpaste with fluoride when your child is 2 years old. Use
toothpaste with fluoride earlier only if your child’s doctor or dentist
recommends it. You can discuss the
correct use of fluoride treatments and fluoride-containing toothpaste with your
child’s dentist. Inaddition, you can go to the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention website, to learn how young children can use fluoride-containing
products to prevent dental fluorosis. http://www.cdc.gov/oralhealth/publications/factsheets/childrens_oral_health/
brushup.htm. In some regions in
the United States, community drinking water and home wells can contain levels of naturally occurring fluoride
that are greater than the optimal levels recommended by the CDC for prevention
of tooth decay. EPA currently has a non-enforceable recommended guideline for
fluoride of 2.0 mg/L that is set to protect against cosmetic effects. If your
home is
served by a water system that has fluoride levels exceeding
this recommended guideline, current EPA recommends that children should be
provided with alternative sources of drinking water
21) What can I do to limit my exposure to fluoride?
Talk with your dentist about the best use of fluoride to
prevent tooth decay. In adults in the U.S.,
there is little concern about unwanted health effects even
from the combined level of fluoride
from all sources. The main sources of fluoride intake for a
child are from swallowing toothpaste
and from water. Fluoride toothpaste is effective for
preventing tooth decay and does not
contribute to fluorosis unless it is swallowed. Because
children under 6 have poor control of their
swallow reflex, they tend to swallow much of the toothpaste
on their brush. Parents or caregivers
http://www.cdc.gov/oralhealth/publications/factsheets/childrens_oral_health/brushup.htmhttp://www.cdc.gov/oralhealth/publications/factsheets/childrens_oral_health/brushup.htmhttp://www.cdc.gov/oralhealth/publications/factsheets/childrens_oral_health/brushup.htm
should supervise their child’s tooth brushing, ensuring that
that the child uses only a small pea-
sized amount of paste, spits out the excess paste, and
rinses well after brushing. For parents of
children under two years of age, check with your dentist
before using fluoride toothpaste.
Water fluoridation is beneficial for reducing and
controlling tooth decay and promoting oral
health in children and adults. Recent estimates of
reductions in tooth decay can be credited to
community water fluoridation. You can check with your local
water supplier to see how much
fluoride is in your drinking water. Because high levels of
fluoride are generally the result of
natural background levels, consumers served by private wells
may want to have their water tested
by a state certified laboratory. You can find one in your
area by contacting your state water certification officer. Contact information for
your state can be found at http://water.epa.gov/scitech/drinkingwater/labcert/.
22) Are there methods I can use to remove fluoride from my
drinking water at home? For example, boiling or use of commercially available
water filters and units.
The typical charcoal-based water filtration systems used in
most homes do not remove fluoride from water. Boiling water does not remove fluoride. More costly distillation and reverse
osmosis are treatment nethods that have proven to be effective for removing fluoride
to below 4.0 mg/L. If you
choose to use home water treatemtn, make sure that the filter you use is
certified to address your concerns.
There are several independent American National Standards Institute
(ANSI) certified organizations that test and certify home water treatment
units. More information about
these organizations and other issues related to your water safety can be found
at
http://nepis.epa.gov/Exe/ZyPDF.cgi/20017JNB.PDF?Dockey=20017JNB.PDF
23) Should my children stop brushing their teeth with
fluoride toothpaste?
Children over 2 years old should continue to brush their
teeth with their usual fluoride containing toothpaste. Questions specific to your own child
should be discussed with your child’s dentist or pediatrician. See parent tips at See Brush Up on
Healthy
Teeth: http://www.cdc.gov/oralhealth/publications/factsheets/childrens_oral_health/brushup.htm
24) Should I reduce the number of times I brush my teeth
daily?
Continue to brush your teeth at least twice a day. Adults
and children 2 years of age and older
should brush their teeth preferably after each meal or at
least twice a day, or as directed by a dentist or doctor.
http://water.epa.gov/aboutow/ogwdw/upload/2005_11_17_faq_fs_healthseries_filtration.pdfhttp://www.cdc.gov/oralhealth/publications/factsheets/childrens_oral_health/brushup.htmhttp://water.epa.gov/scitech/drinkingwater/labcert/
Office of Water (4606M) EPA 815-F-11-001 January 2011
10
No comments:
Post a Comment